DVA Claims for Aggravation of a Pre-Existing Condition: What Service Has to Show

You may have brought an old sporting injury or childhood asthma into the ADF, only for service to make it worse. DVA claims for aggravation of a pre-existing condition exist for that situation, though they follow different rules from claims where service started the problem.

Here we explain what DVA tests, what acceptance covers and where that cover ends.

Veteran at a local sports oval, where an old sporting injury can later become a DVA aggravation claim

Start Your Claim Today

Get expert help with the entire claims process and secure the entitlements you deserve. With zero upfront fees, you only pay for successful claims.

Book a Free Consultation

In this Article:

What Counts as Aggravation for DVA

Aggravation means service or certain treatment made a condition worse or contributed materially to it.

This page centres on one claim type: a problem that began for another reason, which service later worsened.

How the Condition Started

The MRCA, at paragraph 27(d), accepts two origins for it:

  • Before you served, or between stints: You had the condition before enlisting, or it began between periods of service at a time you were not serving, which can happen to a Reservist
  • While serving, for another reason: It appeared during your service, yet service itself did not trigger it

An old rugby knee from school, or childhood asthma fits the first case. The second case can be an illness or an off-duty injury.

An injury suffered while on duty may instead be accepted in full under DVA's on-duty test.

In both cases, service that came later must have worsened it or been a material factor in it. For this claim type, DVA's guidance on aggravation adds that service must not have started the condition.

If service did start it and DVA has yet to accept it, you claim it as service-caused instead. Our initial liability explainer walks through that route.

Service can also worsen a condition DVA accepted earlier, including one accepted under a former Act. The FAQ on conditions DVA already accepted, plus the section on earlier Acts below, covers those cases.

Worse Underneath or Worse on the Surface

The Act splits worsening into two kinds. Each one is tested differently.

  • The condition itself becomes more serious: DVA's manual on onset and worsening calls this clinical worsening. What sits underneath has to change by more than its normal course would explain
  • Only the symptoms or signs flare: The Act deals with this in section 30, while the condition beneath stays the same

Does the change have to last? DVA's manual gives the rule its delegates apply: the worsening can be temporary, unless the relevant SoP demands permanence. A Federal Court ruling underpins that rule.

Each SoP, made under law, lists what can bring on one condition or worsen it. So check how your own SoP is worded.

The RMA, the medical body that writes SoPs, takes a firmer line: its FAQ page insists the worsening be permanent. That FAQ section is guidance, so it cannot outweigh the court ruling the manual follows.

So DVA may still accept a temporary worsening, unless your SoP says otherwise. It must still be more than a passing change in the condition itself.

Support tied to the aggravation lasts only while its effects do and impairment payments need a lasting impairment.

Claims That Look Similar but Differ

Worsening also comes up in other claims. These are not aggravation claims in the sense used here:

  • A new diagnosis stemming from an earlier accepted condition: Our consequential conditions explainer covers this
  • An accepted condition slowly worsening on its own: This is natural deterioration. Our piece on DVA reassessments explains what can follow
  • The old condition running its natural course: A change it would have gone through anyway does not count as clinical worsening

How DVA Weighs the Service Link

DVA applies its tests in sequence. Your service type then sets the level of proof.

The Sequence DVA Uses

DVA's outline of how claims are tested puts presumptive liability first, then a test for injuries on duty. Both apply to claims from July 2026 on. SoPs handle most other claims.

If a listed condition passes its diagnosis, onset and service tests, DVA's presumptive policy accepts it without asking how service started or worsened it. That presumption needs the right service when an injury happened or before an illness began. So it generally cannot help a condition from before you enlisted.

SoP Factors for a Worsening

A SoP can list causes for when a condition begins and apart from those, causes for when it gets worse. Those cover only a condition present before service, or one that began during it from an outside cause.

Say early knee osteoarthritis was found before you enlisted. Years of kneeling and heavy loads during service then worsened it badly.

DVA would test those years against the SoP's worsening factors. Should it accept the claim, impairment compensation covers only the aggravation's share.

Take the generous osteoarthritis SoP, used for every service type except peacetime. Its worsening factors include a defined trauma involving that joint.

Another is squatting or kneeling for an hour or more on most days. That must have run for at least a continuous year before the knee or hip osteoarthritis worsened.

Its stricter twin wants two years of that kneeling. The worsening also has to arrive no later than 25 years after that stretch. Its trauma factor looks back no more than 25 years from the worsening.

Both versions end on the same factor. It applies when suitable care for the osteoarthritis could not be obtained.

SoPs get revised. If a SoP is revised between DVA's first decision and any review decision, DVA's SoP explainer says the primary decision applies. Our guide to reading SoPs shows how the factors work.

Proof Standards and Service Type

Outside peacetime, service gets the easier reasonable hypothesis test. Peacetime claims must meet a stricter one: balance of probabilities.

With both kinds in your record, DVA's proof-standard policy asks for care to be taken to rule out non-peacetime links before switching to the stricter test.

DVA's MRCA eligibility page notes that service type can also alter the amount of impairment compensation.

When Only Symptoms Flared

No SoP is used for section 30 claims. The SoP explainer mentioned earlier lists them among its exceptions.

DVA's incapacity policy on aggravations describes a Reservist sent home from field training with severe hay fever. Pay and allowances would be covered for the training, but not once that episode was resolved.

DVA's impairment policy for these claims says a Section 30 decision should not label the worsening temporary or permanent. It should not fix an end date for support ahead of time either.

Evidence That Shows What Changed

Think of the evidence as two snapshots, one before and one after. The records below supply them.

Start With a Named Diagnosis

DVA first needs a specific diagnosis. DVA's diagnosis guidance for treating doctors explains that pain alone cannot be assessed.

Your doctor's records should name the actual condition, plus left or right where relevant.

Proof of Your Starting Point

Collect what shows how the condition looked before the worsening service:

  • Earlier treatment notes: Notes from a GP, physiotherapist or specialist you saw beforehand
  • Defence records: DVA checks your service records as it assesses the claim and contacts you if anything is missing. It may not have your full Defence medical history, so if your enlistment medical noted the condition, mention that in your claim
  • Imaging or tests: Scans or test results from both periods, where any exist

DVA has to fix two dates: the onset and when the worsening began. Its onset manual says the onset date needs medical backing.

Veteran discussing his medical history with a GP for a DVA aggravation claim

Your Doctor's Part

The doctors' guidance asks when symptoms first showed and the diagnosis date. It also suggests noting risk factors and possible causes, such as earlier sporting injuries.

A diagnosis already made by another doctor needn't be re-examined merely to back the claim, the guidance adds.

Doctors are told to leave the service question to DVA's delegate.

Questions Worth Raising With Your Doctor

At a routine appointment before you lodge, it can help to raise these points:

  • When did symptoms of this condition first appear?
  • How did it affect you before the service in question?
  • What changed and roughly when?
  • Has it gone past its usual course? Has it lasted?
  • Which earlier injuries or risk factors play a part?

Being Open About Your History

DVA cannot accept a condition if, when enlisting or serving, you wilfully and falsely denied having it or ever having had it. This rule, in the MRCA's section 34, covers aggravation claims too.

Its wording needs both parts: the statement was wilful, and it was false.

Weak Spots to Fix Early

Spotting the weak points early shapes your evidence. Watch for these gaps:

  • No named condition: DVA cannot assess pain by itself
  • Service started it: Unless DVA already accepted it, the claim should rest on cause, not aggravation
  • The change fits the usual course: Normal progression doesn't count as a service-caused worsening
  • A SoP factor fits only in part: DVA's guidance on reasonable hypothesis claims says the facts need to be consistent with every element of a factor

What Acceptance Brings

DVA's aggravation guidance, linked earlier, says acceptance makes the entire condition service-related. Even so, the Act still tags it as aggravated, so some support tracks only the aggravation.

Impairment Rated on the Worsening Alone

For an aggravated condition, impairment compensation covers only what the aggravation added, in impairment and in lifestyle effects. Section 70 of the Act sets this limit.

DVA's rules for rating aggravations treat the earlier part like an unaccepted condition. They send assessors to the chapter on partial contribution in GARP M, DVA's impairment rulebook.

In practice, the steps run like this:

  • The assessor rates the whole impairment: This covers everything the condition now causes
  • DVA judges the aggravation's share: It relies on medical advice and GARP M expresses the share in steps such as about a quarter or about half
  • A table turns that share into points: Only those points count for the aggravation

Medical advice drives the split. DVA's form for assessing aggravations, D9500, has the doctor divide the impairment into an underlying share and an aggravation share. If that can't be done, the form lets them say so.

Minimum Points for an Aggravation

Say the aggravated condition is your only accepted one. Then the aggravation's share alone must reach 10 points.

A lower minimum of 5 points covers hearing loss. That figure also holds for lost smell or taste and a toe or finger that is lost or unusable.

DVA's impairment payments page lists those minimums. A later increase for that aggravation is paid only if the rise it causes reaches a minimum of 5 points.

Ratings combine as shown in the table of DVA impairment points on our site. Compensation also waits on a needs assessment, as DVA's needs assessment explainer sets out.

Treatment, Income Support and Rehabilitation

A White Card, DVA's Veteran Card summary explains, funds care tied to conditions DVA accepts. While you still serve full time, Defence provides your care.

For an aggravated condition, White Card treatment covers the whole condition while service's effect on it lasts. Under section 283, that treatment ends if the aggravation stops or service's material contribution does.

Incapacity payments work in a similar way. The aggravation must be a reason, whole or partial, why you lost work that week.

Rehabilitation goes further. It still applies when the first problem, not the aggravation, causes your impairment.

Job-seeking help is just as broad, even if the first problem is what limits your work.

Veteran on an exercise bike during rehabilitation for an aggravated condition

Aggravation and Gold Card Points

An impairment total of 60 points opens one path to the card. For details, see our page on Gold Card point thresholds.

Suppose one aggravated condition is all you have accepted. Section 281 then counts only the aggravation's points, which must reach 60 and stay there.

If an Earlier Act Covered the Condition

Perhaps DVA accepted your condition under a former Act that no longer takes fresh claims. That acceptance stands and no new MRCA test applies.

DVA's transitional policy on aggravation claims says an aggravation you claim from July 2026 onward gets a separate MRCA decision. It makes no difference which old Act covered the first acceptance, or when the worsening happened.

Claims already in DVA's hands before that month differ. Each stays under its original Act.

Lodging an Aggravation Claim

Lodge it like any other new liability claim and name the diagnosed condition. Explain when it began and which parts of your service made it deteriorate.

Ways to Lodge

Start in MyService by choosing Initial Liability. Staff at Veterans' Access Network centres and DVA offices can also help face to face. Or ring DVA: 1800 838 372.

Paper lodgement remains open to anyone without an advocate. DVA's claims guidance asks you not to book or pay for extra medical reports before lodging. The exception is a report DVA asks for and approves.

Our DVA claim lodging guide lays out the process.

Before the Decision Arrives

DVA may cover some care while it considers the claim. For mental health, DVA's NLHC scheme can fund treatment without any liability claim, provided you qualify.

Open Arms runs counselling that costs nothing, stays confidential and is there at any hour. Its number is 1800 011 046.

If DVA refuses, a review is possible. Our appeals explainer covers your options and deadlines.

Veteran relaxing at home with her dog after lodging a DVA claim

How We Approach Aggravation Claims

In aggravation cases, the initial liability service we offer centres on evidence of what changed. Our first question is whether service may have started the condition, since only the worsening counts toward an aggravation's rating.

When acceptance comes, our team can then prepare a permanent impairment application.

We charge fees and stay independent of DVA. Our whole focus is DVA claims and any entitlements they bring.

When Service Made an Old Problem Worse

We have supported over 10,000 veterans through the DVA claims process.

An aggravation claim depends on a firm diagnosis, a record of your starting point and proof of what service changed.

For a view on whether your history could support an aggravation claim, contact Veterans First Consulting.

Written by

Tom Kliese
Co-Founder & Director

Tom Kliese is the Co-Founder and Director of Veterans First Consulting, Australia’s leading private veteran advocacy firm. With a background in business operations, systems design, and leadership, Tom partnered with Kevin to build a professional, high-impact service that supports veterans through the often complex DVA claims process.

Tom is responsible for strategy, team development, and ensuring every part of the business runs efficiently and with purpose. His focus on structure, accountability, and exceptional service standards has helped shape Veterans First into a trusted name in the veteran community — known for getting results quickly, accurately, and with genuine care.

Under his guidance, the team has supported over 10,000 current and former Defence members — helping veterans and their families achieve life-changing outcomes.

‍

Common DVA FAQs

Have other questions?
Contact us so we can help.

Yes, if later service worsened it or contributed materially to it. The other tests still apply. DVA's material contribution policy says the part service played must be more than trivial but need not be large.

It may count under section 30, as a worsened sign or symptom. Treatment can keep going while the aggravation does. Incapacity payments apply in any week it stops you working and no end date is set in advance.

Impairment compensation stays possible under the section 30 policy mentioned above. It still needs a stable, lasting impairment that meets the minimum points. Payment then runs only while the aggravation lasts.

If the MRCA covers that acceptance, the worsening counts within that condition. If an earlier Act applied, see the section on those Acts above.

For an MRCA condition where you kept serving after it began, DVA's rules on further aggravation say service probably added to any worsening.

Only clear proof of a cause unrelated to service would change that.

They help, though other evidence counts too. Exact dates are not always needed, as the doctors' guidance says a rough month and year will do for many long-term conditions.

The same tests apply. GARP M gives all your psychiatric conditions a single combined rating. Where some of them are not accepted it uses the same partial contribution chapter.

Having had it before enlisting is not grounds alone to refuse the claim. The aggravation rules cover that very case, if service worsened it and you never wilfully and falsely denied having it.

Yes, section 29 covers treatment the Commonwealth funded or gave you for a service condition. Unintended effects of treatment given under Defence regulations count too. If that treatment worsens another condition, or just its symptoms, the Act can accept it.

START YOUR CLAIM

Book a Free Call

Join more than 10,000 veterans in getting the support they deserve. Leave us a note and our experts will be in touch shortly to discuss your new claim or claim reassessment.

Zero upfront fees – only pay for successful claims

10,000+ veterans served – we know what we're doing

Australia's largest DVA advocacy group

Sorry, your submission failed. Please shorten your responses and try again.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Sorry, your submission failed – some company networks and browser extensions may block our form. Please try again in a home network or private window, or kindly email us your details.

Explore Related Articles